Most of us in Stratford, whether new or life-long residents, are acquainted with Sterling Community Center, formerly called Sterling House. It’s the Victorian/Romanesque mansion on Main Street that was built on family property in 1886 by the prominent New York City lawyer, John Sterling.
To the left of that stately structure, however, is a circa 1790 wood-frame late-Georgian/Federal style house. In the mid-to-late 19th century it was purchased by Captain John William Sterling, whose wealth was generated as a commander of ships involved in American trade with China.
Known as the Sterling Homestead, this was the Sterling family’s primary home, firmly anchoring them in Stratford’s maritime history. Captain Sterling and his wife, Catharine Tomlinson (Plant) Sterling had three children: Catharine, John (see above), and Cordelia. When Capt. Sterling died in 1866, the house remained with his widow. Daughter Catharine later married Rufus Bunnell, and they and their children also lived there. (John, Catharine and Cordelia in their later years lived in Sterling House, and it was Cordelia who gifted it to Stratford upon her death in 1931.)
In 1976, the Sterling Homestead became a federally registered historic place, due to its architectural integrity and the family’s many ties to Stratford’s history. The house stayed within the Bunnell-Sterling lineage until the town acquired it in 2021.
The most recent descendant to reside in the Sterling Homestead was Cynthia Sterling (Deery) Pincus Russell, Ph.D.,LCSW, who died on June 11, 2020. She was the great-granddaughter of Catharine Sterling Bunnell, and the great-niece of Cordelia Sterling. She was also a devoted champion of Sterling House and its role as a community center.
As a therapist, Cynthia practiced Psychosynthesis and used the first floor for her ACT II Counseling Center. In addition, she rented offices to other therapists. One of those was Stratford resident Orna Rawls:
“When I came on board in 1982, the upper floor was rented to a young couple. On the ground floor we shared a waiting room and three therapy offices. My office, in which I practiced till 1995, ran the length of the house, practically kissing Sterling House property. It had a grand piano and a rope-pull elevator, draped in red brocade. The elevator, Cynthia told me, was used by her grandmother, Rebecca Bunnell, to go to her bedroom on the second floor. The house was surrounded by a black metal fence. It may have been original. Hard to know. But Cynthia had all kinds of ideas, one of which was to replace the nice metal fence with a picket one. The picket fence rotted, the paint peeled and it became an eyesore. Another of Cynthia’s ideas was to remove the asbestos that protected the wooden wall from the radiator. That resulted in a fire in my office.”
Fortunately for all of us, the house survived that long-ago fire. And now, something has been done about that picket fence.
Chris Aurelia, one of the core people in revitalizing Will Geer’s Shakespeare Garden, had an idea. Knowing that the Sterling Homestead is due to become the new home for the Ruby and Calvin Fletcher African American History Museum, it occurred to him last summer that removing the decaying mid-1990’s picket fence would only enhance the historic structure while the details are being sorted out for rehabilitating the building.
Chris wrote a proposal with his idea for replacing the fence. He courteously sought and received the approval of Jeffrey Fletcher, creator and Executive Director of the museum, who would become the new tenant. Chris’s next step would be to contact the mayor’s office.
As luck would have it, on October 5th he encountered Mayor Chess at the Shakespeare park. Before Chris could even make his plea, the Mayor, knowing Chris’s work with the garden, asked him to do something to improve the look of Sterling Homestead. Chris told him his plan and the Mayor was all for it. Then came submitting the proposal to the Historic District Commission and Public Works.

L to R: Chris Aurelia and Lynn Muniz
The approval came through on Thursday, November 5th. On Friday, November 6th, working all day despite the rain, Chris and other members of the garden group removed the old fence but left the posts standing. White chain was then attached between each post in a gentle drape. The goal was to have the whole thing ready on Saturday, November 7th, in time for the Veterans Parade. They reached that goal, with enough time left to make cookies to hand out at the parade. These devoted folks have also been working to clear the overgrown vines and weeds that surrounded the foundation.
There’s much to be done on the building itself, but the work of these volunteers has shown well-deserved honor and respect to a long-time resident of Stratford—the Sterling Homestead.

L to R: Val Sarosky, Mariette Lange, Lynn Muniz


